Sunday, March 15, 2009

THE STIMULUS MANIFESTO


While commenters on the “Let’s Have A Revolution” series presented here at the Swash Zone and on parallel posts at Thinking Out Loud have had varying opinions, it is heartening to note we have found some common ground. I thought it would be helpful to summarize the series.

On The Economy:

Many of us agree a refund is a poor way to stimulate the economy and could be better spent creating jobs. Bringing back business and providing low cost loans for new business creation by those with a solid business plan.
Include investments in agriculture to produce cleaner, cheaper, better foods.

Fair trade agreements that are ACTUALLY FAIR to US businesses.

Improve the infrastructure and improve transportation methods, including developing new modes such as a high speed rail system. Include the improvement and development of greener, more abundant energy sources.

On Healthcare:

This topic proved to be more volatile with widely divergent ideas on how best to tackle healthcare reform.

While some would like to see some sort of personal health accounts, others lean more toward a national health insurance. TAO provided a good example of a compromise program used by Switzerland whereby every citizen is required to pay a mandatory deduction that provides a basic healthcare package. Citizens can then purchase more comprehensive supplemental policies if they so desire.

Another idea presented was establishing state review boards to separate frivolous lawsuits from those with merit, much like a Grand Jury. This could help keep down malpractice insurance costs while not penalizing a truly injured party.

And we mostly agree that we think Americans must be more involved in directing their care and keeping costs down by using the system appropriately.

On Education:

We seem to all agree education is an important aspect of continued economic growth.

Basic skills seem to be lacking among students such as simple math, history, English grammar and spelling and geography.

We would also like to see a curriculum includes courses in goal orientation and achievement and finances, including balancing a checkbook, creating a budget and understanding how credit works and what it costs.

Students and their parents need to be more responsible and teachers need to be supported.

And many support providing scholarships to anyone with the grades and desire for higher education who can’t afford to go otherwise. And why not require some community service in return so they actually earn their education.

We are facing many challenges, both individually and as a nation, but I hope that most of us “every day people” will overcome the obstacles and flourish
.

13 comments:

  1. Thanks for the summary rocky. This has the makings of a fine revolution.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey! How come my request for subsidized crustaceans didn't make the list?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank, Brian.
    8pus, I struggled with that one, but, in the end, I felt I needed to only include those items that had common support.
    Perhaps we can add this as a inkmark?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Rocky, cephalopods don't have ears or eat cake.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm not going to dignify this Commie stuff with constructive criticism -- in fact I'm going to obfuscate and filibuster and maybe hold my breath.

    Do I see one single tax break for yacht owners? Nooooooooooooooo.

    Well, the hell with the land-lubbers - let'em eat barnacles for all I care.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My, have I started a trend with the term 'manifesto" or what?

    Must be spring is in the air and everyone wants something new and fresh....

    ReplyDelete
  7. Must be something in the air...

    ReplyDelete
  8. Nope, not in the air. Try the water.

    Typical humans! Can't reach a consensus on ANYTHING!

    ReplyDelete
  9. The malpractice boogeyman needs to die. The rate of malpractice suits has been flat since 1996, but the price of malpractice insurance spiked after the tech bubble burst in 2001. Doctors are **required** to have this insurance, and they have money, so the insurers saw them as a cash cow to make up for their bad investment decisions.

    http://www.commondreams.org/views05/0110-28.htm

    ReplyDelete
  10. 8pus, we are a contrary bunch!

    Matt, I'm with you, this whole tort reform is simply a vehicle for the insurance companies to make lots of money with little risk. I like the idea of a review board to weed out the dregs, but I would never support any kind of legislation that limits the abilities of truly injured people from being compensated.

    ReplyDelete
  11. On healthcare, I think we should do both a national health care plan and a wide-open essentially unregulated health plan.

    Create the national health plan, set it up however Dem's see fit, with one exception. Those who wish to can opt out and set up their own plan, and not be charged for the national plan.

    I personally think that the national plan is envisioned with the best of intentions, but I also think that it will turn out to be economically infeasable. I think that a health savings account and catastrophic coverage plan will control costs and turn out to be more lasting.

    Many would disagree with me, but here's the thing: If I am wrong, our system will fizzle out and vanish. As currently envisioned, a national plan will force all those who don't agree to play (and pay) along. If that system doesn't work, it will just be propped up until it drags everything else down.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Since so many kids are not motivated in school, I think that there should be a national requirement of community service. I don't mean volunteering at your school during the book fair, but going to different areas of need and seeing how people live and seeing how educated people can help others--and themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  13. One of the major downfalls of our health care system was the introduction of for profit.
    Until sometime in the late 70s early 80s, the healthcare industry was non-profit only and ran pretty well.
    It wasn't until the legislation that allowed profit to be introduced into the industry that we saw skyrocketing prices on everything from tissues to prescription drugs.
    All I can say to those who want to argue the point ad nauseum:
    IT'S NOT WORKING....

    ReplyDelete

We welcome civil discourse from all people but express no obligation to allow contributors and readers to be trolled. Any comment that sinks to the level of bigotry, defamation, personal insults, off-topic rants, and profanity will be deleted without notice.