Sunday, July 19, 2009

The perpetual foreigner

It's funny how the people who spend their lives trying to destroy democracy in America insist that everyone who stands in their way hates democracy in America. Barak Obama, regardless of what kind of a president he will turn out to be in the long run, certainly is an obstacle to the far right and their dubious objectives and of course, to the racists. Someone who doesn't give a damn about the country might find some humor in the myth making and the rebarbate logical fugues that characterize the believers and the creators and the marketers of Obamahate, but I'm not one of them. Unfortunately however, I seem to be on their mailing lists.

I wrote the other day about one US Army Major Stefan Cook who volunteered for duty in Afghanistan in order to generate enough publicity so that his claim that Barak Obama was foreign born would make the papers and boost publicity for the fabricated myth. His case was thrown out of court as expected, but the crusade wears on and it may soon be that you will receive another e-mail diatribe attempting to prove with every fallacy in the book that Obama's three week trip to visit a college friend in Pakistan proves he was travelling under a foreign passport, never had or had renounced his US citizenship, was born in Africa and must have received foreign funding of his education and travels -- which in turn proves a conspiracy to make him president a quarter century later: the same conspiracy begun 50 years ago with the intent of taking an African, Muslim baby and making him the president of the US sometime in the next millennium. It's the same conspiracy that involves the Honolulu newspapers and the Hawaii bureau of vital records.

The serial fallacy proceeds from a false premise: that it was illegal for a US citizen to travel to Pakistan in 1981. It wasn't. Supporting false premises are that it was part of a round the world cruise, which it wasn't and that it would cost a fortune to crash with a college buddy for three weeks, which it doesn't. It's worth reading the screed at Snopes.com simply as an example of poorly crafted, disjointed and clumsy fallacy and a lesson in the power of bigotry to overcome one's ability to spot it.

I should point out that Snopes has debunked so many of the products of the hateful underground that it itself was recently the subject of an e-mail and blog assault attempting to "prove" that it's owned by Liberals and so it's facts weren't facts even if independently verifiable.

I've made it my practice to denounce these never-ending viral e-mails and to hit reply all when doing it. I've irritated people, I've infuriated people, I've lost friends, I've made enemies -- but I've kept some sense of self-respect because I've not let lies and slander and subversive plots pass me by unhindered. Whoever it really was who told us that all evil needs to prosper is that good people look the other way was absolutely right. I hope you'll throw these things back at the perpetrators and the traitors as well.

10 comments:

  1. No matter how many "friends" and aquaintances you lose Fogg, you'll always have us! :)
    You know, this kind of relentless, senseless screed makes me feel like standing in front of a brick wall and just bang my head repeatedly - except it would hurt and I just can't muster enough actually outrage at such idiocy to want to hurt myself.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This just floors me. I made my own post on this after reading yours and the articles you linked. I can't believe this nuttos are still trying this.

    ReplyDelete
  3. About this Cook cuckoo, if I were to go bonkers over every “voices in the head” nutcase taken away in a paddy wagon, sooner or later I’d go cuckoo myself and end up in a paddy wagon. One irony is that Cook’s cuckoo lawsuit cost him his job. Serves him right. But this concerns me more:

    According to this Media Matter Report, Lou Dobbs repeatedly said on his radio show that President Obama needs to "produce a birth certificate" and that Obama's birth certificate posted online has "some issues" -- claims that have been dismissed and even ridiculed by his CNN colleagues.”

    Dobbs is far more dangerous, in my opinion, because of his media exposure and his ability to reach millions of listeners, he has it within his power to create a real case of mass hysteria. This is no longer journalism. Time to write CNN and demand his removal.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dobbs seems to latch on to things he can get hysterical about until he's squeezed out all the ratings he can get. This is the latest and to me the most surprising since for this to be true it would have required a collaboration between people with no interest in common over 50 years with no leak whatever and most of all, it would require that someone knew half a century ago that a mixed race kid from Hawaii would one day run for president. It's absurd.

    The original certificate has been examined and found to be genuine, and his birth notice was found in the papers and there has not been a word from the people who keep vital statistics in Honolulu that his records are not recorded there. I don't think they are in on some sort of conspiracy either.

    Again, compare Cronkite and Dobbs and despair.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yeah, I am in the dog house with most of my extended family because I refused to just 'delete' the emails that they would forward knowing full well that they were wrong, misinformed, or just downright evil...

    No, I had to go on and tell them exactly what was wrong, what I thought of those who saw nothing wrong with being part of spreading vile crap, and then....I had to tell them why I thought just deleting garbage was not the correct answer...

    Well, now I get none of the Obama stuff from my Illinois aunt and uncles and I get none of the Bush hatred from my Mom...

    Of course I now have to deal with the fact that since Hillary did not win the nomination my mom has decided to let her racists roots show and she has toned down the Bush stuff and started helping my aunt and uncles in Illiois....

    Fight it folks, it cuts down on the crap in your inbox and it also cuts down on the number of gifts you have to buy at Christmas! :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Don't forget- these people believe the earth is 6000 years old.

    If they will believe that, they will believe anything.

    Unfortunately, Evangelical Christianity is a centuries old mechanism (going back at least to Cromwell) for training people to give up their independent thought processes, and believe whatever they are told. And it works, sad to say.

    I fear that many of them are unreachable by logic, decency or anything else. We will have to live with them as long as they are alive.

    ReplyDelete
  7. TAO, how is the cigarette smoking withdrawal going?

    ReplyDelete
  8. "unreachable by logic, decency or anything else."

    A CNN poll the other day showed 15% don't believe there were manned landings on the moon. over 60% believe the Noah's Ark story.

    People aren't content to be their humble selves any more. Everyone has to be somebody and what better way to be somebody when you're nobody and know nothing, than to jump on the denial bandwagon and thus acquire what looks at a distance to be a personality. It takes no intelligence and no knowledge -- you just put you hands over your eyes and blow.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Captain Fogg,

    I agree with what you said, but there is also a lot of anger and belligerence behind this kind of stuff too.

    If the Republicans have done a great job at anything, it's getting people to take their frustrations out on the wrong people. Believing that men never went to the moon is more benign than buying into the notion that Obama is a communist, but both views lie on a continuum.

    ReplyDelete

We welcome civil discourse from all people but express no obligation to allow contributors and readers to be trolled. Any comment that sinks to the level of bigotry, defamation, personal insults, off-topic rants, and profanity will be deleted without notice.