Of course I'll be condemned by some for hard heartedness, if not outright treason. I'm only arguing for a sense of proportion, but any balanced and reasonable viewpoint is so condemned in today's America. We're a radicalized, polarized nation choking and strangling on our own anger, yet cherishing it, nourishing it and hoping to preserve it in ritual, in perpetuity: a new anger for the ages. At least some powerful people hope that to be the case. Grieving people being so easy to manipulate and exploit, as some funeral directors know.
Some bits and pieces of the World Trade Center steel framework are being distributed to towns in my area. The Navy SEAL museum in Ft. Pierce now has a chunk and another arrived in my town a few days ago. The local paper printed photos of people kissing the rusty steel, touching their rosaries to it to make them extra holy and others simply hugging the metal, weeping.
The flag wrapped bits of steel arrived escorted by a motorcade over a quarter mile long. Military, law enforcement and veteran's motorcycle clubs accompanied it all the way south from the Georgia border like a funeral procession.
"Our objective is to eventually put this steel on every corner so that people never forget,"said a retired New York homicide detective. That even includes my tiny, unincorporated crossroads town which has no other monuments of any kind. He expressed hope that one day there would be a holiday in every state honoring the policemen of New York. He promised never to forget.
Of course it wasn't all maudlin lamentation, there was plenty of anger still, even though bin Laden, most of his henchmen and all of those who perpetrated the attack are dead. Former detective Dennis McKenna promised that his son was soon going off to Afghanistan, where the perpetrators no longer dwell, to "whack one of them." Bagpipes were played, America the Beautiful was sung, Holy Water was poured on Holy Steel and then the bandwagon moved on.
said one Vietnam veteran. I wish it had done so, I wish all the other war memorials had made us more reluctant to make wars, but we're hardly stronger. We're far more divided, our economy has suffered from trillions of borrowed dollars turned to smoke. There is a bigger economic divide and the tear-shedders in their sackcloth and ashes want to sacrifice every bit of social progress since the 1860's, impoverishing the already debt-ridden majority while enriching the aristocracy.
"Let these pieces of steel remind us of the 2,973 men and woman who sacrificed their lives and, unknowingly, made our country and people become even stronger,"
Never forget that we're victims. Never remember how we victimized millions abroad in an uninvolved country. Always remember that "they" hate us and always complain when we attempt to make peace.
But how long will we actually remember and how long will we see this sad period in the same dim light? Surely half of our country no longer remembers 12/7/41 as the date that will live in infamy, nor the Battleship Maine on 2/15/98 or the burning and sacking of Washington DC on 8/24/14. People will forget. It won't be the worst thing that ever happened any more.
Some of those pre-teens who are too young to remember will absorb the tailored and fitted viewpoint they have thrust upon them at the moment, but their children will live in a vastly different world and one in which this country will not have the same status and those 3000 saints and martyrs won't really compare with the millions and millions dead in other places we wouldn't get involved in because "they hate us."
"I know that Osama bin Laden did the whole thing,"said an 8 year old. Perhaps he'll remember that, perhaps not. Perhaps he will learn some more comprehensive history, perhaps not and it's more than likely there are events to come that will make the death of a few thousand seem insignificant in comparison. No, I'll never forget I won't forget going to the Red Cross office to donate blood and not being able to get there for the crowd. I won't forget the feeling of national unity that was so soon hijacked and exploited and used as a tool, and excuse to wage war at home and abroad. I won't forget the overwhelming, commercially distributed fear and xenophobia and lust for battle either, but I'm old and the world belongs to the young - or soon will and the myth of 9/11 will go where it goes, not where I predict it will go.
As always, very well said.
ReplyDelete9/11 was a dark day in our history. We had to grow up and face the fact we are not invincible and some people really, really hate us and what we stand for.
ReplyDeleteI am sorry that nearly 3,000 people died senselessly. Some maybe even most were good people, hard working and loved their families. No one has mentioned anything about their politics and we can surmise there were probably a significant number of liberal types as well as conservatives so no braying about this being a punishment from God.
Never forget? Forget what? That 3,000 people became part of a national tragedy?
How many remember that on the Trail Of Tears 4,000 Cherokee alone lost their lives to exposure and disease during that grueling forced march.
How many remember the countless slaves beaten and tortured to death after being forceably removed from their native homeland? And I say countless because no one thought it important enough to try and estimate the number of senseless deaths of black slaves - I think a conservative estimate in the 10s of thousands may be far too low.
Who walks the Trail of Tears and weeps for the Humans who died there?
Who walks across the fields of former plantations and cries for the lives so brutually taken?
Where is all the patriotic rhetoric in honor of these events in our history?
I am sorry for those who died and the families they left behind. I feel sadness and compassion for them all and I am in awe of the men and women who risked their lives that day and lost them. They were working in service to their community and should be recognized for their selfless sacrifice. They represent what is best about our country.
But how easy it is to forget the atrocities committed by our own ancestors while railing at those who attack us. It never ends, this senseless violence amongst human beings, does it?
"It never ends, this senseless violence amongst human beings, does it? "
ReplyDeleteIt doesn't seem to. Violence is an attribute of our species and of our closest animal kin. Actually, I'm the kind of guy who gets tears in his eyes at war memorials, even old ones - seriously, but constantly wailing and lamenting and marination in our defeats isn't healthy. It has nothing to do with healing. I have a feeling it is unhealthy, but worse, it's evidence of our being manipulated. Don't forget how it was used to quell protest at a senseless war of conquest that still isn't really over and cost us trillions of dollars, split us in two and made us more hated than ever.
""He insulted me, hit me, beat me, robbed me" — for those who brood on this, hostility isn't stilled. "He insulted me, hit me, beat me, robbed me" — for those who don't brood on this, hostility is stilled."
-From the Dhammapada-
Yes, people hate us for what we stand for, but perhaps it's sometimes what we stand for that we won't recognize. Just what is it that we have appeared to stand for anyway? Freedom is a nebulous and relative term and certainly we've been giving it up by the bushelful, but we've supported more than our share of tyrants and we've killed millions in our passionate hatred of an economic system that seems never to work and collapses under it's own weight. Millions.
So when I hear people like Mitt, doing the patriot dance and telling us we're the greatest country ever in human history, I can't escape the odor of mendacity and I can't help feeling we're being set up for more of this once again.
Rage is a very dangerous emotion and so is self-pity. We need to remember that too, as long as we're listing things never to forget.
Another good post, Captain, and what I've thought about 9/11 and our reaction to it.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if our overreaction is a symptom of a nation facing its decline and a way for us to deflect our attention away from that fact and believe our troubles are from an enemy from without rather than the real enemy within--ourselves.
Capt. Fogg,
ReplyDeleteOh, I know – the irony is, the good feeling that everyone touted right after 9/11 lasted about a week, and everyone went right back to cutting one another off on the freeway and generally behaving like selfish fools. But that's just human nature, saith this dinosaur. Peace be upon Great Mother and Father T-Rex, I don't even have a self to be –ish about.
The public is wont to behave like a blubbering big dummy when it comes to displays of public emotion. I find it distressing to watch. And the "never forget" claim is about the phoniest thing I've heard lately – do we really need Professor Nietzsche to tell us that forgetting is one of the most ruthless of civilization's tools? Never forget? More like "always forget."
All the same, none of this is to undercut the shocking thing that was done a decade ago by bin Laden's goons: we shouldn't entirely lose our capacity to be stunned by the sheer inhumanity of religious fanatics and ideologues who would plot for months to fly big jet planes into a building full of ordinary people just trying to live their lives. What's objectionable is simply the notion that this event was unique in human history. If anything, it's typical.
Capt.,a fitting, and clear-eyed assessment of the mythology that we've carefully crafted from 9/11. It was a horrible tragedy but it was not the greatest tragedy of all time nor the greatest wrong of all time, as Rocky so eloquently recounts. I don't mean to lessen or belittle the horror of 9/11, but I do wonder what it is that we work so hard not to forget. Is it our anger and need for revenge? I think that both emotions are best let go to dissipate in the healing that can come from the passage of time. I do wonder what future generations will remember of 9/11 and whether they will still be as the Capt. so succinctly puts it, "... a radicalized, polarized nation choking and strangling on our own anger, yet cherishing it, nourishing it and hoping to preserve it in ritual, in perpetuity: a new anger for the ages."
ReplyDeleteI will never forget 9/11, nor will I forget the assassinations of JFK, MLK, and RFK. Moments of lived history are hard to forget. At different ages and stages of my life, I bore witness to these events with an impalpable and gnawing feeling - that my world had also changed and would never be the same. I suppose the meaning of 9/11 turns on what we mean by the words ‘never forget.’ A simple remembrance? A symptom of trauma? An act of defiance? Or a character flaw?
ReplyDeleteI can accept remembrance, empathize with trauma, even share a fleeting moment of defiance (I knew people who died that day); but I resent having รผber-patriotism shoved in my face as if there were some public obligation. Ultimately 9/11, like most experiences in life, is a personal one to be felt in our own unique and special way.
Thank you, Captain, for a well-written post that challenged me to think about 9/11.
What disturbs me most is that the Manhattan hole in the ground is being used as a Petri dish to nourish the culture of revenge; the motivation to "go over there and whack one of them" which, of course, we continue to do; pissing away our resources for nothing more than tax-free corporate profit.
ReplyDeletePreserving the image of the enemy, even one who doesn't exist, is right out of the 1984 textbook, beard and all. I fear that 9/11 will be an annual hate session used as long as possible to justify the unjustifiable and that's why they don't want us to forget.
Sometimes they do want us to forget -- forget the almost uncountable dead from Japanese suicide missions, the murder of millions of civilians in gruesome fashion, by everything from air raids, to firing squads, to mass rape and germ warfare. Nobody remembers the Rape of Nanking or the hundreds of thousands of women sold as sex slaves. Remembering wasn't part of the post-war plan, so we were told not to and we didn't.
I know people my age who won't buy anything made in Vietnam because "those guys" are still the "enemy" as though they invaded us and forbade us to have elections and as though we didn't murder 2 million of them. Always remember - never remember: two sides of the same counterfeit coin.
I'd better stop before I lapse into profanity again.