Thursday, May 23, 2013

An Extraordinary Moment in our History as a Nation

Just a quick note. I hope everyone who is interested had a chance to listen to the president's speech today either on the radio or television. If you care anything at all about the recent wars our country has been involved in, drone strikes, national security or unjust captivity at Guantanamo Bay, this is one not to be missed. Please look for it if you haven't heard it. I think it took the better part of an hour. The president outlined the case for war rather eloquently. Certainly in a much clearer way than I have ever heard before. Some high points would have to include the case for drone strikes, their legality, necessity and effectiveness when weighed against the alternatives of bombardment, missiles or other forms of conventional warfare. Particularly noting the lack of a legal authority in the countries where members of Al Qaeda and the Taliban are based, capable of helping us to capture those who would harm citizens of the U.S.A. or its allies. Remembering that the president has successfully concluded the conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq, it is telling that he cited the monetary cost of prosecuting just one month of the war in Iraq at its peak as an incredible waste of resources that might have been used to help feed people in Yemen, build up and train security forces in Libya or other tasks of mercy that might ameliorate or alleviate the causes of hatred against the United States, eventually one would hope, marginalizing the forces of terror that would seek to attack us. He referred to "reservoirs of good will." I, for one, would love to see U.S. foreign aid take the form of agricultural and humanitarian efforts instead of merely being blank checks to the manufacturers of weapons systems. Finally, and you must congratulate our friend from Code Pink for her sense of timing, he outlined the case for closing Guantanamo very succinctly. Obliterating any argument from less civil or responsible members of congress who have moved to prevent the relocation or trial of prisoners in recent years. I thought it was an extraordinary moment in free speech and democracy when he held a conversation with the lady from Code Pink. A more conservative president would have had her hauled off to a federal detention facility within moments. He did not agree with everything she said, but he gave her the credit for being a voice that needed to be heard and being a valid participant in a very important discussion.

6 comments:

  1. ''the lady from Code Pink//

    that was no lady..... that was a rude, disruptive voice from the fringe. Free Speech is, well, free, propriety is civil..... and she was less than that. You do not heckle the President at a press conference. A republican, a democrat..... you must respect the office, if not the man......I am serious. I will disagree with anyone, and I do, .....but that was unacceptable...... Obama showed extreme restraint, civility. I do not agree with his stand on drone strikes. Congress has blocked his efforts to close Gitmo.....Republicans have been as obstructionist as possible......but dammminti, whether it is Bush, Reagan, Clinton, .... you respect the President during official presentations.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks okjimm,

    I appreciate your point of view. Lady, woman, heckler, whatever. I thought it was really cool the way the president engaged her. That's how groovy of a president that he truly is. But I agree with you to a certain extent. I will never forget when the Rolling Stone magazine came to the defense of Bush 41 when citizens disrespected the office in an inappropriate way.

    Bush 43... Meh! Say what you will. Cheney and Rumsfeld were the true devils.

    I also wanted to say that I appreciated the way the president affirmed the value of the Muslim-American community. To his credit, Bush 43 also expressed the same sentiment.

    ReplyDelete
  3. ohohoh.... I thought Obama was uber-cool. I have never seen a president under such continued duress. Word is..... some are upset....because he is sleeping with a Black Woman in the White House. Scandal! Outrage!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I haven't had a chance to watch the whole speech, just pieces like the Code Pink heckler, and the drone strikes argument. You know me, I love all the presidents speeches and will love this one too, after all the Republiscums found a lot to criticize, therefore it was brilliant! Right? :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I can't watch Mr. Obama's or any other president speak from prepared text. It's always in service of a political agenda. Off the cuff speaking, as chancy as it is at times, is a much better guage of someone's true character, command of the facts and general intellectual engagement.

    Barack Obama and Bill Clinton both excel at unscripted remarks. None of the Rethuglicans have been that good at it since before FDR. The meatpuppetking, Boy George, demonstrated a stunning lack of factual knowledge and zero intellect or curiousity. He always looked like a deer in the headlights if the question was actually a question and not a "cue" from some friendly "journalist"--Hello, Jeff Gannon.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes, he is good at it -- a sign of intelligence and of the habit of thinking and that's why they had to start giggling at him using a teleprompter as though every goddamn president since LBJ hadn't. Reagan couldn't have ordered in a restaurant without one.

    I think he looked more like a 'possum than a deer -- the latter having a certain dignity not often found in Republicans.

    ReplyDelete

We welcome civil discourse from all people but express no obligation to allow contributors and readers to be trolled. Any comment that sinks to the level of bigotry, defamation, personal insults, off-topic rants, and profanity will be deleted without notice.